You were attacked. You protected yourself, or someone you love. And then you were the one placed under arrest.
That feels like a contradiction, but it happens regularly, and it doesn't mean your self-defense claim has failed. It means the claim hasn't been fully heard yet.
As a former federal and state prosecutor, I know how these files get reviewed after an arrest. Here's what happens next in Louisiana, and what you can do now.
An arrest is not a verdict
Since Aug. 1, 2024, Louisiana law has required a peace officer to consider evidence of self-defense when deciding whether there's probable cause to make an arrest (Code of Criminal Procedure Article 390).
That's an important protection, but it doesn't guarantee you won't be arrested. Officers make that decision quickly, often before all the evidence is available. If you were arrested, the self-defense question moves to the prosecutor, and possibly to a judge or jury.
What to say to police
In the minutes after a violent encounter, adrenaline affects memory. Details come out of order. Small inconsistencies are captured on body cameras and 9-1-1 recordings and later presented as contradictions.
You have the right to remain silent and the right to a lawyer. You can tell officers you were attacked, point out anyone who's injured, and say you want to speak with a lawyer before giving a full statement. Asking for a lawyer is not an admission of anything, and it can't lawfully be used against you.
Never lie to police. A false statement creates a separate problem and can damage a claim that would otherwise be strong.
Preserve the evidence now
Self-defense cases are often decided by evidence that disappears quickly. If you or your family can do so safely and lawfully:
Photograph injuries, damaged property and the scene as soon as possible.
Write down the names and contact information of witnesses.
Note any cameras nearby: doorbells, businesses, parking lots, traffic cameras. Many systems record over footage within days.
Keep any texts, voicemails or messages showing prior threats.
Don't post about the incident on social media, and don't discuss it on a recorded jail line.
Give all of it to your attorney. A lawyer can request formal preservation of footage and records before they're lost.
The charging decision
After an arrest, the district attorney decides what, if anything, to charge. That decision is discretionary, and it's one of the most important points in the case. A defense attorney who gets involved early can present self-defense evidence before charges are finalized.
In cases where the charge carries a possible life sentence, such as second-degree murder, the Louisiana Constitution requires a grand jury indictment.
The state's burden, and your deadline
Act 729 of 2024 made two changes that shape every self-defense case in court.
The state must disprove self-defense. When self-defense is raised under R.S. 14:19 or 14:20, the state has the burden to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you did not act in self-defense. You don't have to prove that you did.
You must give notice. If you intend to claim self-defense, you must give the district attorney written notice within 10 days after the state moves for discovery under Article 724. A court may allow later notice for good cause, but no one should plan on that.
This deadline is one of the clearest reasons to have counsel early. It's easy to miss in the middle of an arrest, a bond hearing and everything else.
There may be a civil case, too
The same incident can lead to a civil lawsuit. The rules there are different. Under Code of Evidence Article 1105, a defendant in a civil case who raises self-defense generally must prove it by a preponderance of the evidence. A criminal case and a civil case can move on separate tracks, and what you say in one can affect the other.
If you're in this right now
If you or someone you love was arrested after an act of self-defense anywhere in Louisiana, the most useful thing you can do this week is talk to a lawyer. Schedule a confidential consultation today. 📞 (844) JABYNOG / (844) 522-9664 | bynoglaw.com/contact
Sources
1. La. C.Cr.P. Art. 390 — Burden of proof; justification of self-defense raised; probable cause. Louisiana State Legislature. https://legis.la.gov/Legis/Law.aspx?d=1386574
2. Act 729 (HB 819), 2024 Regular Session, Résumé Digest. Louisiana State Legislature. https://www.legis.la.gov/Legis/ViewDocument.aspx?d=1385276
3. La. R.S. 14:19 and 14:20. Louisiana State Legislature. https://legis.la.gov/legis/Law.aspx?d=149985
4. La. Const. art. I, § 15 — Initiation of prosecution.
Frequently asked questions
-
Yes. Officers must consider evidence of self-defense, but they can still make an arrest if they find probable cause. The self-defense claim is then decided later in the process.
-
In a criminal case, the state must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that you did not act in self-defense.
-
Yes. You must give the district attorney written notice within 10 days after the state moves for discovery, unless the court allows later notice for good cause.
-
You have the right to remain silent and to ask for a lawyer first. Talk to an attorney before giving a full statement about what happened.
-
Yes. A civil case is separate, and the burden of proof works differently.
Disclaimer: This article is general information about Louisiana law, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Outcomes depend on the specific facts of each case. Bynog Advocacy & Defense is located in Lafayette, Louisiana, and represents clients statewide.